Notches and camera punch holes are often criticized because they compromise the display experience rather than truly solving the front-camera challenge.
breakdown of why many users and tech reviewers consider them bad
1. Breaks Immersion 📱
Notches and punch holes interrupt the screen’s symmetry, making videos, games, and full-screen content feel incomplete. Instead of a clean rectangle, you’re left with visual cut-outs that constantly draw attention.
2. Wasted Screen Space
Despite claims of “more screen,” these cut-outs reduce usable display area. Status icons get pushed to the sides, and apps must adjust UI layouts to avoid the notch or hole—often resulting in awkward spacing.
3. Inconsistent App Experience
Not all apps handle notches and punch holes properly. Some hide content, others stretch UI elements unnaturally, leading to inconsistent visual experiences across apps.
4. Distracting During Content Consumption
While watching videos or playing games, punch holes and notches can be visually distracting, especially against light or bright backgrounds. Once you notice them, they’re hard to ignore.
5. No Real Innovation
Notches and punch holes are temporary design compromises, not real solutions. They exist because under-display camera (UDC) technology isn’t perfect yet—not because cut-outs are better.
6. Aesthetic Downgrade
Many users prefer clean, uninterrupted displays. Compared to pop-up cameras, sliders, or advanced UDC tech, cut-outs often feel like a step backward in smartphone design.
7. Limits UI Design Freedom
Developers must design around these cut-outs, which restrict creative freedom and sometimes force awkward UI placements.
The Better Alternatives
Under-display cameras (when matured), Slim, uniform bezels, Motorized or slider cameras (mechanical, but immersive)
Comparison Table: Notch vs Punch Hole vs Under-Display
| Feature | Notch | Punch Hole | Under-Display Camera |
|---|---|---|---|
| Display Immersion | ❌ Poor | ⚠️ Average | ✅ Excellent |
| Aesthetic Appeal | ❌ Outdated | ⚠️ Acceptable | ✅ Premium |
| Usable Screen Area | ❌ Reduced | ⚠️ Slightly Reduced | ✅ Full Screen |
| App UI Consistency | ❌ Inconsistent | ⚠️ Better | ✅ Best |
| Innovation Factor | ❌ Low | ❌ Low | ✅ High |
| Future-Proof | ❌ No | ❌ No | ✅ Yes |
Final Take
Notches and punch holes are functional compromises, not user-centric innovations. They solve the selfie camera problem cheaply but at the cost of immersion, aesthetics, and usability—making them a necessary evil rather than a good design choice.
0 Comments